Help me decide..

I am the last one to be able to help, because i can't make up my own mind! the reasons given for selecting either are exactly what's going through my mind! so i am not here to help, but rather to offer my empathy in your dilema, because i am in the same boat!

Tammy I love the eternity band but Edyta makes some good points that I didn't think of with the eternity band! Too bad when we meet for dinner you can't just have the bands with you and then we could all decide(lol)!! Sorry I'm no help!

I know Ann.. Maybe you need to take a trip to MI and we can help each other out.. Or drive the jeweler crazy.. lol

I vote for your option #2, pic #1. The custom thing is scary to me because I don't know if I will like something until I see it! I like the eternity band the best, but as others have said- I just don't think it's practical unless you won't EVER gain or lose weight. My size 5 e-ring is already waaayyy too loose for my comfort, with only a 7lb weight loss and it started out really tight- I'm so glad he didn't get the eternity band because I will get it sized!.

Tammy what shape are the side diamonds of your e-ring?

The shape of the side diamonds are round.

then I think either the eternity or the 5-stone will work.. I think there's no need to pay more for a custom ring.. If it were me I'd get the eternity

I don't know if you've made your decision yet.

My friend has an eternity ring and just had a baby. She finds that when she picks up the baby she finds the inside of the rings gets hooked in clothes and can scratch and lately she hasn't been wearing her wedding band.

Just a thought, because I've yet to decide and I'm a huge fan of eternity rings.