Help me decide..

I know there have been a few thread lately on wedding bands but I keep going back and forth on what I should get. There are three options, 1) a custom design band that matchs my E-ring 2) 5 stone, 1 carat diamond ring or 3) 2 carat eternity band (each stone being 10 points) (see below for pictures of 2 & 3)

Now to refresh your memory, my E-ring center stone is emerald cut and two diamonds on each side (two on each side are .25 & .11 points per side) If I did a custom ring they would match my E-ring exactly with the center stone being either .25 or .40 (depending on which one looked better and aligned better)

i like the second one...

Sherri, I'm so indecisive sometimes.. I like the eternity band idea but because they never have my size in it throws off the look of it..

I really love eternity bands, my wedding ring is not one, but I am hoping my fiance will buy one for our four year anniversary which is one day before our wedding...so my vote is for the eternity band.

I, on the other hand, am not a fan of eternity bands. If you are not a woman of leisure, its hard to keep it nice. You will bang it on things and it will get scratched and not look so pretty in a few years. That is my thing, that is why I would not get one. All my rings look kinda banged up on the back. Not my E-ring, but it will happen.

I think a custom one is the best idea. That is what I am going to do Tammy, and I have an emerald cut as well. I will get something with diamonds the same size as my side diamonds and find something nice to go where the stone is, maybe bigger, depends on what looks good. This way, you know you will be happy with it, and, no one else will have one like it.

Yeah that was my orginal thought Jules, but I'm so worried after all the money it costs to make a custom one that I won't like it once it's finished and I'll be so made at myself. Plus I know i'll have issues with the bands flipping around all the time, and if I bond them together, then when we are mountian biking or snowboarding or whatever I wouldn't be able to wear my rings..

I think my problem with the whole wedding planning/wedding band decisions is that I over think EVERYTHING and I end up driving myself crazy.. lol

This is so hard because im in the same boat as you...i love the eternity one but have decided to go with half way around..these are my reasons why:

a) eternity is uncomfortable to wear according to my mom

id rather have something half way around and have bigger diamonds for more of a sparkle

c) if you refer back to ann's thread where she is trying to decided on rings i posted my e-ring with an eternity band and it just doesn't look right...doesn't sit properly under

d) Terry said he'd buy me an eternity for one of our anniversarys

e) u can't get them resized

f) if u get 3/4 of the way around still looks like an eternity and no one will know it isnt unless u wave..see janets heres is 3/4 of the way i thought it was all the way around...well its beautiful

hope this helps..good luck

Tammy also it isnt that expensive to make a custome ring..ive looked into prices and it will come out to be exactly the same...and yes we girls overthink everything dont worry bout that it just makes the process more fun and we love to drive ourselves insane anyways

Well the price of the eternity band that I would get (2 carat) is about 3k and the custom ring (1 carat) would be the same price. Cain said he would get me whatever I want because it's a one time decision that I have to live with for the rest of our lifes. Maybe that is weighting down on me too.. lol