BM Earrings Poll

Alright, a few months back you guys decided what starfish necklace for me to pick for my BM's and I love them. So, now I want to get them earrings. I already bought a pink bracelet (dress colour) and the starfish necklace, here is a pic:

 

Now I want to know if I should get them starfish earrings or something different altogether.

 

Here are the earrings I am thinking about, these

 

or these

 

So my question is, do I get starfish earrings, or its too matchy matchy and I should get something different?

 

Thanks girls.

I like the earrings but do they have a post version? Non-dangly ones like these? IMHO I think that the dangly ones might be a little too much. Just a thought-

 

I totally agree with you, but 2 of my BM's only wear dangly earrings, they don't like post ones. So, that is why I am looking for dangly. The other BM does not care either way, but I think they should all match. And I got different earrings and bracelet for my MOH.

hmmm, those are pretty but I don't love the matchy-matchy too much. Personally, I never wear earrings AND a necklace AND a bracelet at the same time. Maybe just two of the three. Maybe just add some small silver studs to keep it simple?

I like the 2nd pair of earrings, but I think it might be too much. What about sterling silver studs or simple hoops? I'm dealing with this same dilemma (same necklace) ... but since my BM dresses are halter-style, I may forego them wearing the necklace at the wedding and just give it to thm as a gift and get them some earrings that match the dress for the wedding...

This is what I am wondering, if its too much matching and just to get something plain. Or, don't get them earrings at all. 2 of them are dangly earring girls and one had diamond studs, so no point getting her something fake, lol. That is why I thought dangly, but not sure where to go on this one. Do I get pink like their bracelets and my necklace, or do I go all silver, and just not get them any.

i agree that it may be too much - but i am also an "anti-matchy matchy" person. they're cute -but with the necklace it might be too much of a cute thing. ya know?

I do know, that is why I am asking all of you. lol I am not a matchy matchy person, but I know 2 of my BM's are, so I thought they might like it. But since most of you think its too much, I will probably go with my gutt on this and get them something else. or none at all and just let them wear their own.

I voted for "no matchy-matchy", I love eclectic looks, so that was too much for my taste. If you decide against, I would say go for something simple in silver, not pink, so it is more flexible for them later.

well heck - if they like it, may as well get it for them!