Which Mugs to Use?

[foxytv]

As some of you know ... I was very unhappy with the outcome of my logo on the travel mugs that I ordered. So, the company sent me a new shipment. The new mugs are smaller and have no handle, but the aqua color is similar and the logo is the correct size.

 

Now, my decision has become -- which ones do I use for the DW (the others I can use for the AHR, although we won't have enough for everyone who has RSVP'ed).

 

I LOVE the first mugs. They are larger, so will hold more liquid, and have a handle. But the design is super small and many of the lids don't screw on tight. I ordered more than the number of DW guests, so I can probably weed through and find enough with tight lids (hopefully).

 

The second mugs I LOVE the logo size ... but the mugs are smaller, have no handle, and will hold basically the same amount as the plastic cups that the resort provides. But the lids do stay on tight.

 

Here is a pic of the larger mug w/ handle. (note how small the design is)

 

 

This is the smaller mug w/o handle (sorry its not my actual mug but the logo design is big and beautiful on it).

 

 

Here is the logo, but it is all coral/orange in color on the mugs.

 

[Gretchen]

Wow. That's a tough one. I like cups with a handle and I like the bigger size of the first cup. But, if it isn't what you wanted to give people, I don't know. I say do what you want - the people there will have no idea of the other mug. They will just be happy with whatever you give them!

[DanielleNDerek]

Tami I know you weren't happy with the first mug because of logo size but i think it looks fine. If I was a guest, i think i'd prefer the one with the handle so my hand doesn't get cold from all the daquiris, margaritas, and pina coladas I would be planning on drinking! Plus they are bigger to hold more drink. That is if you can find enough lids to fit on them.

[Betsy]

I like both of them! But if I was a guest at your wedding I would want a handle I think! Especially after having a few drinks in that awesome mug!

[chicago88]

I say use the larger ones, if you have enough lids that fit tightly, for your DW!

 

Save the small ones for your AHR.

[LCBride2007]

so question - why didn't the company send you a replacement shipment of the original mug you ordered?

[LCBride2007]

oh, to answer your question ... why not put a mix of the mugs in there. that way you can please everyone! just like on this forum, you're going to have some people prefer the one w/the handle, and some prefer the other (I'd choose the other). if people don't like the one they're given, they can trade!

[boscobel]

Love what Ann said. Mix it up and then no one is dissappointed!

[amandalovesryan]

i agree, mix it up. but i also agree, why didn't the company replace with what you ordered?

[Jenn3878]

I agree too! Mix it up!!