I started a similar threat like this and most of the answers that i got were pretty much OOT bags. I started with the basic OOT bag items hand held fans water proof bags- for cameras,ect tums nail files tylenol tide pens, ect I had a hard time choosing the bags because I didnt want to spend alot of money. All the times that my FI and I have been to the islands our drawstring bookbags have been really useful. So we opted for that style over the tote bags. Although I think the tote bags are prettier, the drawstring bookbags are more functional IMO. So now I am woking on making them awesome. I just got my first personailzed item shipped this past week. I got my dad a really nice Zippo lighter from beachthemedweddingshop.com. It says Father of the Bride Jamaica 11/11/11 So I guess what I am saying is what gifts you give will depend on how many ppl you have and how close they are to you. I would say do OOT bags and spruce them up with something nice that is personalized. Just consider whatever you get ppl in their OOT bags or what not has to be able to travel home with them. (I am kinda scared they will take my dad's lighter so i am going to tell him to try to hide it somehow). Anyway, good luch with your decision making