Hi Maggie! I was in the same boat as you about a year ago, trying to decide between Dreams and Now. We almost went with Dreams Punta Cana, as we absolutely love their wedding gazebo area, but parts of the resort don't look as modern as we'd like. We went back and forth but in the end decided to go with the newer more intimate resort.
What are your pros/cons, or important factors? Are you leaning in one direction more than the other right now? If so, then you should probably just trust your gut!