Have you done a site visit? The feel of Hilton and Half Moon are very different. All depends on what you're looking for. We felt like royalty at Half Moon...they have everything there. From the villas to the pools to the breathtaking spa. The Hilton was also nice, but it felt more like your usual all-inclusive resort. There was a wedding during the weekend I was there, and the bride didn't do much to make it private. For example, the day before her wedding, the bridal party was meeting for a pre-wedding lunch filled with toasts etc, but since they couldn't make a reservation at any of the restaurants for lunch because reservations arent permitted during lunch, they all ended up waiting in the long line and coordinating to get tables that were close to each other. If it were me, I would have at least gone to an off-site restaurant to make sure we felt more exclusive. So, there are always ways to make it how you want it.