i researched all of them, so i'm happy to share what i know. i'm with you, i didn't like the format and protocol for honeyfund. honeymoon wishes seemed nice but i found it to be the most expensive option. you might like to check out depositagift.com that's who we chose and we're really happy with it. we liked it because the interface is really nice, clean and warm and the registry part felt like a store's online registry to us, which we thought would be easier for guests. also they offer the full wedding website with pics etc for free. i'm not a huge paypal fan and was looking for a site with a credit card option, which deposit a gift has. they offer phone service too, and to us seemed like the most straightforward and flexible service. we started ours as soon as we got engaged b/c everyone kept asking for the engagement party and it has worked out really well: we've gotten gifts, guests are happy and we've had no regrets. the experience has been as promised.