Hi Allie~ We booked everything but the wedding through Celebrity. They had us working with the Wedding Experience and it was an experience to say the least. LOL They kept trying to sell us into a package, but I needed so much more......I was looking for something a la carte, since we are 60 people on the cruise and a few more meeting us on the island the day of the wedding. On the bright side, my new wedding date is November 25th - which is Thanksgiving this year....and that happens to be my favorite holiday. So I'm very optimistic that it will all work out. The tough part has been all my DIY stuff that has the 24th written all over it - do I start over? At this point, I don't think so. The beach at Nachi Cocom looks beautiful (I just googled images) Having lived in South Florida for most of my life, I will say that, based on the pictures, Nachi Cocom is better than Key West. You made a great choice. Warmest regards, Mish