I am also thinking about a small wedding in Key West. We are taking a cruise with stops in Key West and Cozumel. I had my heart set on Cozumel but it will be easier to actually get married legally in Key West. I looked into Weddings To Go, their prices were okay. I am also looking into having a lunch reception at the http://www.rooftopcafekeywest.com/. The lunch prices were great. I would like to offer lunch, drinks, and cake right after are mid morning vows.