inanna

I haven't stayed there, but it's location would be a deal breaker for me. The location is in what's called "New Town," which is a bit far from the action of Key West. Most people visiting Key West want to stay in "Old Town," fairly close to Duval Street, where they can walk to most of the sights and beaches/marinas. If you prefer a fairly calm resort, the Southernmost Resort properties are on the quiet end of Duval (Southernmost Hotel is often very reasonably priced). Hyatt, Pier House, Ocean Key are some of the nicer resorts on the other, "party" end of Duval. There are also lots of privately owned, adorable B&Bs and cottages throughout old town. We've had good experiences at the Mermaid and the Alligator and many family members have enjoyed staying at Courtney's Place. Here is a good map of Key West neighborhoods: http://vacationhomesofkeywest.com/key-west-map.html. I prefer to stay in the Heart of Old Town, Historic Seaport, or Downtown. Truman Annex is also very nice (mostly very high end cottages/vacation rentals). Bahama Village is fun to go to during the day, but I've been told to avoid it at night.

Yes, this is pretty common everywhere. I somewhat understand the logic - accidents are much more likely to happen with big gatherings, esp. for celebratory events where alcohol is involved (this is why many rental houses don't allow weddings at all). We rented 2 beach houses in Islamorada for our wedding, but the owner agreed to waive the $1500 event fee...this was in 2009, so I doubt they waive this fee anymore. Back when I was looking at properties, it seemed like newer owners were more willing to negotiate. Most rental agencies I contacted required a $1000-2000 event fee and were not willing to negotiate.

Absolutely beautiful pics Stina! Congratulations!!!

You may want to look into the Sundy House in Delray Beach, Fl (in between Ft. Lauderdale and West Palm Beach). Its not actually on the beach, but they have a gorgeous gazebo in a garden/lagoon area of the property. http://www.sundyhouse.com/