UPDATE:
I ended up chosing the Secrets Maroma Beach.
Reasons:
1) The price ended up dropping to a lower rate
7 Nights out of JFK on Jet Blue Non-stop in a Jr Suite Ocean Preferred Club Room / Transfers/ Insurance came to $3155.94 I went through Liberty Travel - she originally gave me a quote of $3600, I told her I saw the same thing on Expedia and she matched it for us. If you need the name of the TA I used (she is in Hartford, CT) PM me and I will let you know her #.
2) My fiance is all about the beach and the water. After reading so many reviews on the other 3 hotels I thought the beach at Maroma sounded like it was the best.
I only have a month to plan this, as my wedding Date is the 7th or 8th of Sept (both days are available at the resort, I just need to pick one)
It's just my fiance and I getting married so there shouldn't be too much planning to do. Most important to me is the photograher/videographer and then my hair and makeup. Wish me luck!!
Happy planning