Congrats and welcome to the forum! You need 150 posts to open attachments, are you only looking into one day or are you flexible with the date. Try seeing which days you could have a later wedding on, good luck with the planning!
Well I'm slightly biased because I also have dress #2 in my running and I love it. It sounds like you are leaning more towards 1 though and it goes well with your dress. Honestly they are both great choices.