Hi Lori, to the forum! If the quality of beach is an issue be sure to read reviews on Tripadvisor too. I also love the El dorado Royale but have read that it is one of the many beaches that is suffering from beach errosion. (Some resorts are putting really ugly huge sandbags just out a short distance in the water). I would suggest THe Royal Playa del Carmen, you can bring in outside vendors with a small fee and the beach is gorgeous! Good Luck with your planning!