FI and I went through this last summer when we were choosing our photographer. One of his friends is a director/photographer who does AMAZING work, but I was still against using him. Not because I thought his work would be bad but because a) I know he doesn’t love shooting weddings, and he would be doing it as a favor to us which would make me feel bad, We wanted to invite him to the wedding, and we’d rather have him there as a guest instead of having to work the whole time, and c) What if he got another paying gig for something amazing, i.e. to shoot a music video or something, and he couldn’t do it because of our wedding? Or what if he takes it, and bails on us and we have no photographer? I just wasn’t comfortable with the idea. Plus, wedding photos are really important, and even though I know he would do a great job, what if I wasn’t happy with something? I couldn’t say anything to him because he’s FI’s friend. Also, it might sound weird, but I think it would be harder to be natural in front of the camera if you’re doing it with someone you know than with a total stranger. That’s just me though. Also because he doesn't usually shoot weddings, I know he wouldn't take the time afterwards to edit them etc. He was just going to throw them all on a disk and send them over to us.
So for all of those reasons, we chose a different photographer. FI still doesn’t agree with it, because it would have been cheaper to use the friend, but it is what it is! I really wanted to use someone who does weddings all of the time and who has a passion for it. I think the passion comes through in the final product.