Hi Ladies:
Thanks for all your input!! I seriously don't know how I'd survive without you.
I liked #1, and FI (yes, I took him with me) liked it, but he hasn't seen #2. Which I really liked. Unfortunately the store that had it, has a no pictures policy.
I'm going to try to go back tonight at try it on again. I'll see if I can't sneak a photo...
But based on your votes, and me too, I'm leaning toward #2.
I've said it before, and I'm sure I'll say it a zillion times more, but I LOVE YOU LADIES!!!