We had 40 guests at our Paradisus wedding, and all of our guests were excdeptionally pleased with the food. Even the buffett was really good, IMHO, but we are NOT picky, 5-star restaurant eaters. We don't care much for chain food - and usually go to independent restaurants when at home ... and have no complaints about the food (except the burgers at the grill by the beach were undercooked).
The people with us were all different types of travelers, some were world travelers who love luxury and top-notch food, others had never been at an AI before.
Everyone wants to return.
Our rehearsal dinner and reception food were fabulous - absolutely no complaints from us or any guests.
It is totally a subjective thing.
We could not be happier or more content with our decision to marry at PPC.
Also, we honeymooned at PPR and I actually preferred the food at PPC (so did hubby) ... especially the buffett was better at PPC to us ... but again, it's subjective (we loved tha Pasta Station at PPC that wasn't available at PPR).
But all of the a la carte restaurants were fabulous at both resorts -- at least they were to us.
We really couldn't see why people would complain about the food at either resort..