We were actually going to go there in Dec 2005, but due to the hurricane, we did not go, the resort did get hit.
It was on the front cover of a thick best resorts magazine that year, after we had booked, so we knew it would be a nice place.
Looked at it briefly for the wedding, I cannot remember what the issue was. It may have been that they didn't allow children or they didn't have wedding packages available.
Sorry I am not much help, but I know we plan on stopping by there next Feb to see what we missed
Good luck in your search!