Hi Rachel, To be honest, I'm not a fan of either (ooh harsh, sorry). Aftere a TON of research I've decided to fly out my own photog. I don't like either of their packages. I don't feel that they give enough images.
I recently found a photog in PV named Elizabeth Lloyd. The images she sent me seemed pretty good and her price was great. I posted all her info in this thread. http://bestdestinationwedding.com/forum/t5083 I would do more research, but she's worth a try.
In the end, I couldn't find a photog in PV had the style I wanted and FI just agreed to fly someone in.