Thanks for all your input everyone! I'm sorry it took so long to respond, my internet has been down :-(
I've decided to use either Mypublisher or Shutterfly to make my In-Laws and album and to make a Honeymoon album. And for my actual coffee table book, I’m going to take Jean-Marcus up on his offer to make a less expensive professional one.
It will take a while to get everything designed and printed, but I’ll share the results!