WOW.. note to self NEVER get anything from Kay..
We do all our jewelry shopping at Jareds, and they are awesome, what I also like about them is that you can always trade up.. Which is great, because it makes those 1.5 carat diamond studs more obtainable (for us at least.. lol) Cain got my E-ring through them and my wedding band and they went above and beyond when they did some work to my wedding band so that it worked better with my E-ring.
Definitly try to transfer over, you'll be MUCH happier..