Ultimate TV Question: DirectTV or Comcast?

So I've been a member of Comcast for nearly 4 1/2 years now. I originally went with them because at the time, they seemed like the best option for internet/television provider. Well now that my bill is like $140 a month and I don't really have any movie or HD channels, I'm starting to wonder if I'm getting screwed! So I have to wonder, would I be better with DirectTV and then just stick with Comcast for my internet or what?

Do you have Fios in your area? i know my sister had Comcast for the internet and her bill was getting ridiculous. They got Fios in their area and are happy with that now. As far as cable... I would def go with DirecTV. They have so many channels and if you do need to go the HD route I am pretty sure they have the most channels out there! Also, I think TIVO is just the best DVR service out there... We live in a monopolized neighborhood. The builder happens to own the company that our houses are wired with for phone, internet and cable service... They bill it right into our HOA fees. We can't really afford DirecTV on top of that...

I have Direct TV and love it - you can get TIVO or DVR. I actually have my internet and phone with the same provider AT&T which was less than going the cable internet route.

I'm pretty sure they do. I think its like $5 a month, but so worth it!

We select cable according to the carriers in our area so there is Comcast, verizon, cablevision, direct tv, time warner, etc. We have cablevision which is better than direct tv or any other carrier like that because you avoid the outage issues that come with direct tv. If it rains, no service. If there is a technical isue - you are SOL. I may not like the pricing of cable but Cablevision and Verizon are great options for us.

I had Direct TV and was so happy with it! It had everything I needed and way cheaper than Comcast! My FI has Comcast, and it's the worst thing ever! The DVR box will all the sudden freeze, or just not work at all! There's always bogus charges on their bills and their customer service sucks!!!

Either of them are better than Time Warner though which I have at my apartment!!!

Definitely Direct TV!!!!

I have DirecTV and love it! Althought I have been trying to get information regarding AT&T's U-verse which is like Fios. It allows have only 1 central hub DVR that functions on upto 4 TVs (that's all I know, lol). The main thing is that I can have my home phone, internet and television all together and it will be just a little more than what I pay for just my DirecTV, at least that is what they are telling me. I've made no moves yet, because I am please with my current service. If anyone has info let me know.

we love our directv - comcast is evil AND expensive. and if you have to have a phone line for your house, consider something like vonage. waaaay cheaper.