Help me pick!!!

Hey everyone! I'm new on the boards, but have been lurking for a few weeks... I'm getting married in Jamaica in January (woohoo!) - have the location, about 20 guests, and am down to 2 dresses...

The model pictures don't do either dress justice, but they wouldn't let me take pics until I bought. Which of these do you think I should pick? I love them both and just can't decide!

#1 Nicole Miller

#2 Nicole Miller

Can't wait to hear what other destination brides think!

# 2 all the way!!! I've always loved that dress!!!

I picked number two as well, I like both though!!

IMO the bottom on #2 is more fitting for a beach wedding, so pretty!

dress #2 is absolutely beautiful . . .

I am in the minority....I picked #1 because I dont really like the crinkly bottom on the second one. Good choices though!

I also picked number 1. I love it.

i like #1 better also

I picked #2 - it is a beautiful dress. I've always liked it and I think it would like fantastic for a beach wedding!

Good luck deciding! can't wait to see pics of you in it!

I'm totally torn...

#1 is more classic and white, and is really flattering, and a little easier to walk in. On the other hand, it has a built in bra-back to keep it in place, which will be hot on the beach.

#2 will probably be more comfortable, and I love the material, which is a funky off-white metallic. It's definitely more beachy. It's also less expensive.

That being said, my fiance is wearing a tux... and I think #1 will look better with that.

Keep the votes coming!